Monday, February 1, 2010

Blog # 1

1)
-How do you know?
(b) Something meaningful from this reading by Green, was the concept that society, from the dawn of time, has always tried to categorize us by being one of two genders; male or female. It's interesting to me that we have to follow the rules of gender or else we are isolated, degraded, or even chastised. One in One-hundred people have bodies that differ from those of standard male and female bodies, so what happens to them? Ignorance and fear takes over society and then that population is ousted from societies fictional representation of what being "human", "female", or "male"is. Green makes it clear that what is shown on the outside is often a veil for many, and that gender shouldn't always have to correlate with sex.

-"Night to his Day"
(c) It never dawned upon be that I was living by societies rules when i make assumptions about gender, and that I myself was doing gender without thinking it. Lorber states that gender is a "socially constructed [status]". I never imagined that others societies, other than Western, could allow other genders, or recognize other genders, but at a cost. What I don't understand that if we, a generation that is more modern, advanced and "somewhat" educated in a sense, can see that we are all different in many ways, why can't we allow ourselves to see that we don't have to fit into one gender?

-A Continuous Nonverbal Communication
(b) As I was reading Wilchins , a question came along that was meaningful to me. Why has it taken so long for gender's emergence as a civil rights issue? If we as a society are all one human race, why is there the need to have to discriminate or make less of others because of the way they choose to live their lives, and it is the fear of the unknown. For so long society has lived a certain way; either your male or female, act feminine or masculine, right or wrong. We don't have a gray area when it comes to gender. We have rules we have to follow, and if we don't follow those rules, we become unprivileged and lesser than human. It seems to me that even if there are rights that pertain to equality for men and women, what happens to those "equal" rights if you don't fit into the category of male or female, or if your sex is ambiguous. What rights do they get. Couldn't we just have rights for everyone without having to categorize them.

-Gendered Bodies: Feminist Perspectives
(b) A gendered society, as Lorber and Moore puts it, is one where our lives are categorized into men and women, and based on your genitalia, there is a systematic allocation of people in gendered positions that are done through a social process, that might even be unrecognizable. It doesn't make sense that if I was born with a vagina I would have to live a certain way and fall into certain expectations and do certain things because I was born with a vagina. Because of this I feel that the oppression that women have gone through is never-ending. Yes, through time women have "earned" the right to vote, and "earned" the right to an education (in some ways), but we as women continue to follow the rules of how to dress or act to show that society is improving. If I didn't want to wear make-up, or fix my hair in the morning, I would be a hippy feminist that doesn't give a shit about what she looks likes and most likely be called a dyke because of it.

2)
(b)
My brother is sixteen, I think, and since I have started coming to CSUSM he has really noticed a change in the way I think. When I began taking Women's Studies, I think he really hated me, because in just about every conversation I could apply my learnings about oppression. When I was reading "How do you know?", by Green I wanted to ask my brother how he knew we was male. His answer, "You swear, I'm not a fag", and that was it. My brother says that he's all about equal rights at his sixteen years of life, and that he's pretty open to just about anything, but even the concept of gender and how being a "fag" really had nothing to do with him "knowing" he was a male wasn't really a valid rationalization was extremely ridiculous to me. Ignorance comes from fear, and he fear comes from society not being able to accept different views and understand that everyone is different. I thought that this really tied into the idea that people automatically assume that gender comes either in a male or female, and masculine or feminine. Society has made us believe that gender is only acceptable in two ways, and my brother automatically assumed that your either a boy or a girl, gay or straight.

10 comments:

  1. I really like how you pinpoint the differences of masculinity vs femininity, and how society really tries to classify people into these two sub-fields. I agree with you 100% as well on that note. People are people and should be able to live a fulfilled life as they see fit, and not have to worry about if they are living the ideal feminine lifestyle, or vice versa with the masculine lifestyle.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like the story about your brother. It is something that we see everyday. There are so many people who say they are open minded, but then we are so blind to some things like gender.

    ANd also we say that we are open minded, but then like your brother so many people who are accepting use words like fag, and have this one idea about it. It is sad but true what you said about fear, and how we fear what society may think. And we have an idea in our heads since birth and that instills fear in us. Its just ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really really like your personal story about your brother. I feel for him not understanding how he can not be considered a "fag" today. I have a friend who thinks the same way when I started taking woman studies. These concepts are completely foreign to them and they don't understand things that we are learning.

    Our society is NOT completely open minded. There are so many people who are not comfortable with peoples genders and their preferences that we find some even going so far as to attack and kill people. This fear that we have I believe, will continue to plague our society even after we all pass away and our children continue on.

    ReplyDelete
  4. God dammit. I have tried posting 4 times and it keeps deleting them.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree that our society has always tried to categorize gender. That's surprising after hearing the statistics about how not everyone can be categorized as male or female. The labels that our society has created don't apply to everyone. I liked how you pointed out all of this information and asked why it has taken so long to make gender apart of the human rights movement. I agree that it took too long to make alternative genders acceptable in our society. Thanks for the insight, I appreciate your comments.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I was wondering if your brother ever tAlks about locker room bashing?

    ReplyDelete
  7. My friend and I were talking about this class and he told me from an early stage that little boys would bash each for their dick size. I think that's awful. I was never judged for body parts I could changed. But it def shapes our identties from a young age

    ReplyDelete
  8. I really like what you said about your brother feeling fear for what society thinks is not normal. It is so true, like the guys that were in high school with me many felt uncomfortable with concepts about homosexuality. They were just trying to prove that they were men just how society wants them to be like, but they were not understanding and open-minded. I just feel we still have a long way to go.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I liked what you said in response to "Night to his Day" I think you brought up an interesting point about our society seeming more progressive and advanced than others, but then falling behind when it comes to gender. I find it confusing that we can be so forward on certain issues and yet cant wrap our minds around the fact that not every single person will fall into one of two very structured categories.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I think its scary to see how gender rules our lives. The example of your brother perfectly fits mine. My brother ironically claims he is a feminist. Yet hes is always bashing on the gay community. He says things like "well I'm okay with them being gay as long as they don't try anything funny on me." I thinks its funny how straight men have this idea that all gay men want them. As professor Andreas pointed out in class, yea not all straight men are all that.

    ReplyDelete